Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +----- Forum: P5 Discussion (/forum-997.html) +----- Thread: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: (/thread-926187.html) Pages: 1 2 |
Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - JRsec - 07-30-2021 07:18 PM Big 10: Duke, Georgia Tech, Miami, North Carolina State, Virginia Indiana, Maryland, Penn State, Purdue, Rutgers Illinois, Michigan, Michigan State, Northwestern, Ohio State Iowa, Iowa State, Minnesota, Nebraska, Wisconsin SEC: Clemson, Florida, Florida State, Georgia, South Carolina Alabama, Auburn, Mississippi, Mississippi State, Texas A&M Kentucky, Missouri, North Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia Tech Arkansas, Kansas, Louisiana State, Oklahoma, Texas *All but football: Vanderbilt, Wake Forest PAC: Boston College, Louisville, Notre Dame, Pittsburgh, Syracuse# Colorado, Oklahoma State, Texas Christian, Texas Tech, Utah Arizona, Arizona State, California, California Los Angeles, Southern Cal Oregon, Oregon State, Stanford, Washington, Washington State *If anyone drops out Kansas State # East Division is football only. Hoops and non revenues join the Big East This makes any breakaway inclusive of the Big East Why is UNC in the SEC? ESPN will want 100% of the brand and it coves Wake as a partial. It covers all 4 N.C. schools with the SEC and B1G each getting 1 AAU 1 Not. Why is Iowa St in the B1G? The SEC needs hoops and has Missouri. Now you guys can cuss and discuss. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - XLance - 07-30-2021 08:16 PM Carolina will not separate from UVa and Duke, you need to swap Carolina and NC State and you would have something. No problem to get away from State. Carolina will always look out for Wake Forest. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - JRsec - 07-30-2021 08:42 PM (07-30-2021 08:16 PM)XLance Wrote: Carolina will not separate from UVa and Duke, you need to swap Carolina and NC State and you would have something. Well, if you could stay with UVa and Duke in either which would you choose? RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - ChrisLords - 07-30-2021 09:14 PM I could live with that. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - Statefan - 07-30-2021 10:56 PM It's difficult for me to imagine the SEC allowing Kansas in to play football. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - JRsec - 07-30-2021 11:14 PM (07-30-2021 10:56 PM)Statefan Wrote: It's difficult for me to imagine the SEC allowing Kansas in to play football. Possibly, but look at their division. Oklahoma, Texas and LSU would likely want a breather, Arkansas wouldn't complain, and the whole conference is becoming top heavy and a breakaway, which is what Sankey wants, would mean BB schools would become 40% of the total Athletic Revenue instead of 20% and Kentucky would be thrilled. And they are AAU and Missouri's rival. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - ChrisLords - 07-30-2021 11:47 PM These 20-team conferences didn't kick out WF or Vanderbilt. I had the SEC get pretty much anyone they wanted and the B1G getting exposure in the south. Putting Kansas in the B1G west and all 3 Florida school in the SEC East allowed for better break up of divisions. Auburn/Alabama weren't broken up and Michigan/Michigan State weren't broken up. Unfortunately the B1G doesn't get into Florida or Texas which may be a deal breaker for the B1G. The ACC has a Mega-Big East feel to it and is a hell of a basketball conference. ND joins because it is a break away league. B1G ----- South Clemson, Georgia Tech, Maryland, North Carolina State, Virginia Tech East Michigan, Michigan State, Ohio State, Penn State, Rutgers North Illinois, Indiana, Northwestern, Notre Dame, Purdue West Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Nebraska, Wisconsin SEC ----- North Kentucky, North Carolina, Tennessee, Vanderbilt, Virginia East Florida, Florida State, Georgia, Miami, South Carolina South Alabama, Auburn, LSU, Mississippi, Mississippi State West Arkansas, Missouri, Oklahoma, Texas, Texas A&M ACC ----- North Boston College, Cincinnati, Pittsburgh, Syracuse, Temple, West Virginia South Central Florida, Duke, Louisville, Memphis, South Florida, Wake Forest Big 12 ----- Baylor, Boise State, BYU, Houston, Iowa State, Kansas State, Oklahoma State, San Diego State, Texas Christian, Texas Tech Pac 12 ----- North California, Oregon, Oregon state, Stanford, Washington, Washington State South Arizona, Arizona State, Colorado, Southern California, UCLA, Utah RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - schmolik - 07-31-2021 06:25 AM Big Ten Biased 3x20: Big Ten (*from ACC): Florida State*, North Carolina*, Duke*, Virginia*, Maryland Penn State, Pittsburgh*, Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State Notre Dame*, Indiana, Purdue, Illinois, Northwestern Wisconsin, Minnesota, Iowa, Nebraska, Rutgers (Stick them out west to keep everyone else together!) SEC (*from ACC): Florida, Georgia, Clemson*, South Carolina, NC State* Kentucky, Louisville*, Tennessee, Vanderbilt, Virginia Tech* Alabama, Auburn, LSU, Mississippi, Mississippi State Texas, Texas A&M, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Missouri Everyone Else: UCLA, USC, Arizona, Arizona State, Colorado Cal, Stanford, Washington, Oregon, Utah Boston College, Syracuse, Miami, Georgia Tech, Pick One From West Virginia, Cincinnati, UCF Kansas, Pick Four From Remaining Big 12/AAC schools Out: Wake Forest, Oregon State, Washington State, At least 2 Big 12 schools Compromise: Florida State chooses the SEC over the Big Ten. Big Ten takes Georgia Tech instead of FSU, they take FSU's place. Louisville doesn't get into the SEC, Florida State is in Florida/Georgia's division, NC State moves to Virginia Tech's division, Louisville is stuck in the "Everyone Else" conference. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - schmolik - 07-31-2021 08:06 AM Big Ten Goes California Dreaming 3x20 Version: Penn State, Maryland, Rutgers, Ohio State, Michigan Michigan State, Indiana, Purdue, Notre Dame, Illinois Northwestern, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Iowa, Nebraska Colorado, UCLA, USC, California, Stanford SEC Gets Pick of the Litter From the Southeast: Virginia Tech, North Carolina, Clemson, South Carolina, Kentucky Georgia, Florida, Florida State, Alabama, Auburn Tennessee, Vanderbilt, Mississippi, Mississippi State, LSU Texas, Texas A&M, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Missouri Everyone Else: Boston College, Syracuse, Pittsburgh, Virginia, Louisville Duke, NC State, Wake Forest, Georgia Tech, Miami Washington, Oregon, Arizona, Arizona State, Utah 5 of 8 remaining Big 12 schools RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - BruceMcF - 07-31-2021 09:09 AM (07-31-2021 06:25 AM)schmolik Wrote: Florida State chooses the SEC over the Big Ten. Big Ten takes Georgia Tech instead of FSU, they take FSU's place. ... I think the Big Ten's first choice would be Georgia Tech. I understand it is a bit daft, but that's the way they are. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - XLance - 07-31-2021 10:24 AM (07-30-2021 08:42 PM)JRsec Wrote:(07-30-2021 08:16 PM)XLance Wrote: Carolina will not separate from UVa and Duke, you need to swap Carolina and NC State and you would have something.a Actually JR, you had the teams right to begin with. The problem is that you had the divisions all wrong First off, I want to say that the ACC has been fighting an uphill battle since they missed out on trying to lure Penn State away from the B1G. Once that attempt failed, the ACC became the "Turk" after his failed on his attempt to kill the Godfather. We were dead men walking. The B1G caved into Paterno's demands for eastern teams. Paterno wanted Rutgers and Pitt, but got Rutgers and Maryland instead. This was enough to keep Penn State in check and the first nail in the coffin of the ACC. The ACC could have survived and thrived with Penn State and Notre Dame and probably would have become a bigger earner that even the SEC. Now the ACC with even a full time Notre Dame and any other Big 12 team only will prolong the inevitable. The ACC would always be playing from behind and never have the opportunity to be on equal footing with the B1G or the SEC. Plus, the biggest reason not to follow this path is that I don't believe that Notre Dame can be trusted. When Texas and Oklahoma decided to take the money, the paradigm shifted, all of the games were over, and it has become the time to forget about pride and tradition and worry about survival. To that end, Carolina should cozy up to the (I'm choking on the initials) SEC, but demand to control our own division. JR, this is how I would see Carolina, Virginia Tech, Clemson, Kansas and Florida State fitting into the SEC: Carolina, Virginia Tech, South Carolina, Georgia, Florida Kansas, Missouri, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Texas Texas A&M, LSU, Ole Miss, Mississippi State, Alabama Florida State, Auburn, Clemson, Tennessee, Kentucky Vanderbilt and Wake Forest as associates. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - clpp01 - 07-31-2021 10:37 AM SEC: North: Clemson, Kentucky, North Carolina St, South Carolina, Virginia Tech South: Alabama, Auburn, LSU, Mississippi, Mississippi St East: Florida, Florida St, Georgia, Tennessee, Vanderbilt West: Arkansas, Missouri, Oklahoma, Texas, Texas A&M B1G: North: Illinois, Michigan, Michigan St, Ohio St, Northwestern South: Duke, Georgia Tech, Miami, North Carolina, Virginia East: Indiana, Maryland, Penn St, Purdue, Rutgers West: Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Nebraska, Wisconsin PAC: North: Oregon, Oregon St, Washington, Washington St South: Arizona, Arizona St, Colorado, Utah East: Boston College, Notre Dame, Pittsburgh, Syracuse West: California, Stanford, UCLA, USC Central:Cincinnati, Houston, Louisville, Texas Tech RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - bullet - 07-31-2021 11:10 AM (07-30-2021 08:16 PM)XLance Wrote: Carolina will not separate from UVa and Duke, you need to swap Carolina and NC State and you would have something. Agree about UNC. And think in a 3X20 Pac swallows Big 12 while SEC and Big 10 feast on ACC. Notre Dame joins the evil 10. Duke, Georgia Tech, Miami, North Carolina, Virginia Northwestern, Maryland, Penn State, Rutgers, Notre Dame Indiana, Purdue, Michigan, Michigan State, Ohio State Iowa, Ilinois, Minnesota, Nebraska, Wisconsin SEC: Clemson, Florida, Florida State, Georgia, South Carolina Alabama, Auburn, Mississippi, Mississippi State, Texas A&M Kentucky, North Carolina St., Tennessee, Virginia Tech, WVU Arkansas, Missouri, Louisiana State, Oklahoma, Texas PAC: Kansas, Kansas St., Iowa St., BYU, Oklahoma St. Arizona, Arizona St., Baylor, Texas Christian, Texas Tech Stanford, Colorado, California, California Los Angeles, Southern Cal Oregon, Oregon State, Utah, Washington, Washington State Pitt, BC, SU, UL have no place to go but to recreate a BE football conference. WF and Vandy football join in. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - clpp01 - 07-31-2021 11:17 AM (07-31-2021 11:10 AM)bullet Wrote:The chances of Baylor and BYU getting into the Pac-12 are on the same level as the SEC schools disbanding their football programs.(07-30-2021 08:16 PM)XLance Wrote: Carolina will not separate from UVa and Duke, you need to swap Carolina and NC State and you would have something. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - bullet - 07-31-2021 12:02 PM (07-31-2021 11:17 AM)clpp01 Wrote:(07-31-2021 11:10 AM)bullet Wrote:The chances of Baylor and BYU getting into the Pac-12 are on the same level as the SEC schools disbanding their football programs.(07-30-2021 08:16 PM)XLance Wrote: Carolina will not separate from UVa and Duke, you need to swap Carolina and NC State and you would have something. Baylor isn't that far fetched. BYU is a bit of a stretch, but Baylor and BYU are pretty well above anybody else west of Louisville who isn't in the Big 10 or SEC. Geography still does matter some. And even with BYU, they have 5 Pac 12 schools on their schedule in 2021, including USC. They have Stanford in 2022 as well as several future years. They have everyone but Oregon St.,, Washington, Cal, UCLA and Colorado on their schedule just in the next two years. And they had UW in 2019 and Cal in 2018 and 2019, UCLA in 2016 and Oregon St. in 2012. Pretty sure they have played Colorado sometime while CU was in the Big 12 or Big 8. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - JRsec - 07-31-2021 12:07 PM (07-31-2021 10:24 AM)XLance Wrote:(07-30-2021 08:42 PM)JRsec Wrote:(07-30-2021 08:16 PM)XLance Wrote: Carolina will not separate from UVa and Duke, you need to swap Carolina and NC State and you would have something.a Well X, those divisions work just fine since we would have a permanent rival in each division. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - clpp01 - 07-31-2021 12:38 PM (07-31-2021 12:02 PM)bullet Wrote:The is something where athletics simply does not matter. Pac-12 presidents are never going to admit an institution that censors academic research, BYU could be as big a program as Notre Dame and the Pac-12 still would not accept them.(07-31-2021 11:17 AM)clpp01 Wrote:(07-31-2021 11:10 AM)bullet Wrote:The chances of Baylor and BYU getting into the Pac-12 are on the same level as the SEC schools disbanding their football programs.(07-30-2021 08:16 PM)XLance Wrote: Carolina will not separate from UVa and Duke, you need to swap Carolina and NC State and you would have something. Baylor's problem is the combination of being church controlled, their moral code (and at times the lack of it) and not being a research based institution. They aren't as far gone as BYU and for profit universities are but they are on the next level. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - XLance - 07-31-2021 02:46 PM (07-31-2021 12:07 PM)JRsec Wrote:(07-31-2021 10:24 AM)XLance Wrote:(07-30-2021 08:42 PM)JRsec Wrote:(07-30-2021 08:16 PM)XLance Wrote: Carolina will not separate from UVa and Duke, you need to swap Carolina and NC State and you would have something.a I'm sure we'll enjoy Lexington and Oxford (I've always wanted to visit The Grove), I hope we get to go to Austin every other year. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - Statefan - 07-31-2021 02:57 PM (07-31-2021 02:46 PM)XLance Wrote:(07-31-2021 12:07 PM)JRsec Wrote:(07-31-2021 10:24 AM)XLance Wrote:(07-30-2021 08:42 PM)JRsec Wrote:(07-30-2021 08:16 PM)XLance Wrote: Carolina will not separate from UVa and Duke, you need to swap Carolina and NC State and you would have something.a We would enjoy seeing you go there as long as you go there without us and please take Duke with you. RE: Let's Revisit The 3 x 20: - SouthEastAlaska - 07-31-2021 06:19 PM (07-31-2021 11:10 AM)bullet Wrote:(07-30-2021 08:16 PM)XLance Wrote: Carolina will not separate from UVa and Duke, you need to swap Carolina and NC State and you would have something. Obviously dreams here but "if" it was to happen I think you're pretty close to the mark. B1G would be an absolute beast basketball conference. SEC pretty much the same as it is now, absolute beast of a football conference. PAC would be decently balanced in both. JR, make it happen |