northcoastRocket
Hall of Famer
Posts: 19,698
Joined: Aug 2010
Reputation: 47
I Root For: Toledo
Location:
|
RE: MAC WBB Transfer Portal: 2023
(04-03-2023 02:13 PM)kazoorocket43 Wrote: (04-03-2023 07:06 AM)northcoastRocket Wrote: (04-03-2023 05:28 AM)Lester Wrote: (04-02-2023 09:45 PM)kazoorocket43 Wrote: The early transfer portal news may be good for the rockets competitively but they are certainly disappointing for the league. It appears that many of the more talented players, including Felder, Williams, Davis, Wolfe, and most likely some of the best BGSU players will be leaving the MAC. That's not good for a league looking for respectability and the possibility of multiple entries in the big dance. It suggests that the good players see options to maximize their basketball experience outside the league.
Now that players can transfer with no penalty, bad teams seem highly likely to lose their good players, along with teams who change coaches, of course. I agree with you that the news has been bad so far, but we will see how the second half of the transfer process goes. Perhaps some MAC teams will be able to strengthen themselves through the portal, as happened last year.
I understand that worry, but so far, the MAC really hasn't lost many good players at all so far. Of course, that could change some, especially once the fallout at BG is known, but coaching changes are always gonna result in losses, and some players may flip to other MAC teams.
So yes, Felder and Williams are losses for the MAC, but OU was likely not going to be a top team this year, so unlikely that will hurt the conference standing much. Williams maybe the bigger loss in that regard, but can't blame her for moving on from a perennial also-ran to Michigan, which has lost a ton to graduation and transfer already. She might start for them, but at least will be in the rotation. Davis was always going to move on as I understand, and has already played her 4 years, so those types of COVID 5th years are gonna be done in a couple years.
But, of the top MAC players (by efficiency,) those coming back (so far as we know) is a good list. Bass, Becki, Lockett, Cluse, Mikonowicz, Shumate, Skanes, Scott, Wiard ... etc. Graduation has hurt a lot more this year with players like Clephane, Winfield, Stone, Day, Di Augustsdottir, Thall, etc. moving on. Watch the P6 schools and it's like the trade deadline in the pros now as numerous productive, or even star, players jump from one P6 to another. So, it's not just a mid-major issue. All schools will have to do things to keep from losing good players every year.
I assume that most of the players in the MAC are there because the P6 schools did not offer them. So when a player becomes highly effective at MAC level they become more attractive to the bigger basketball schools. And why wouldn't a good MAC player be interested in playing on a bigger stage with more talented teammates? So sure players are jumping from mid majors to P6 and from P6 to the top teams. LSU is an excellent example. Losing record two years ago and a national championship this year. While it is not only an MAC issue it appears to me that it is a more serious issue at mid major level particularly if MAC has as a goal raising the level of respect of the program. P6 schools losing transfers have a better chance of replacing them than MAC schools have in replacing Felder, Davis, Wolfe and Williams. Danger is of becoming a minor league feeding system for the big schools.
It might end up that way at some point, but it really isn't there yet. Only a few top players from the MAC transferring up, and most of those have been due to coaching changes, COVID 5th year decisions, and escaping from bad teams/situations. I am sure that the low majors look up at conferences like the MAC and think the same thing.
Maybe that will change in the future, but we will have to see. There have always been transfers up and down, but it's just that now with the portal people can track them very closely.
UT has not been hurt badly in transfers-out over the years, but they have been helped a lot by transfers-in. UT has had tons of contributors that were transfers "down" from bigger name schools like Bre Harris (Michigan), Tara Overaitis (Michigan State), Haylie Linn (Indiana), Dana Creighton (Indiana), Crunch Jones (Illinois), Nan Garcia (Penn State), Hanna Noveroske (Indiana). Even Jane Roman (one of UT's all-time greats) came from Rice, who I am sure many outside the MAC would see as a step down. So, it works both ways, and if you hinder the ability for MAC players to transfer out, you will also hinger the possibility for players to transfer in too.
|
|