(10-25-2021 10:34 PM)Eagleyed Wrote: Oh and one more. A couple of years ago Conference USA lost the contract to the Battle for Atlantis. Always had a bunch of really good schools in it and we were an auto bid. Never said what we got in return for us voluntarily getting off of it, but I know whatever it was it wasn't good enough. Contracts that force the big boys to play on neutral ground with you is worth almost any price.
I’m curious what happened here because I don’t think it was ever reported, just that one year the B4A field was leaked and everyone was like “huh, no CUSA team this year, wonder if it’s a onetime thing or if it’s permanent.” Turned out to be permanent. Did the contract come up and the parties couldn’t agree to terms? Did B4A cut it early after seeing the Maui Invitational push Chaminade to every-other-year status? Did we pull out because there wasn’t enough benefit to sending a team to (often) get swept by better competition? It would have been nice to get some closure on that. Oh well.
The one thing I will say in MacLeod’s defense is that her visit to ODU probably got us in FBS.
Per a comprehensive story in the local paper, ODU was rejected in casual communications by a number of conferences, and CUSA already had Middle Tennessee, Western Kentucky and Florida Atlantic clamoring for the last spot, but eventually Britt Banowsky sent her to Norfolk on a fact-finding mission:
Quote: Perhaps the most important voice to be heard during those 6-1/2 weeks belonged to Judy MacLeod, executive associate commissioner of C-USA, who made an 18-hour visit to Norfolk on April 23.
She came, as she put it, "under the cover of darkness," on a scouting mission. If she liked what she saw, C-USA Commissioner Britt Banowsky would visit and negotiations would continue. If she didn't, ODU presumably would remain in the CAA.
MacLeod had dinner with Harnage and Selig, and the next day toured ODU's facilities and listened to a presentation from Selig and Broderick.
"I knew the athletic history," she said of ODU. "But until you get there and walk around and get a feel for things, it's hard to judge. You always have questions going in, but every question I asked had already been thoroughly contemplated. There was a plan in place. The commitment to athletics was evident from the facilities and their plans.
"I was very impressed."
Banowsky said that when MacLeod returned to conference headquarters in Irving, Texas, she was enthusiastic: "ODU is pretty cool," he said she told him.
Also some credit to USM’s president at the time, Martha Saunders, for encouraging ODU to reach out to CUSA in the first place.
History won’t remember MacLeod especially fondly but I agree with those who said that she was holding a bad hand dealt by Banowsky, particularly with regards to the media deal and ESPN **** up. I don’t know that anyone could have helped CUSA at that point.
Her biggest sin, I think, was being a private person in a position that benefits greatly from public communication. Fans wanted her to be as combative and forward as Aresco over at the AAC, but what did he do? Same thing as Banowsky/MacLeod — lost a bunch of his best programs, replaced them with market-driven gambles — but also made bombastic public comments about P6 and making runs at Big 12 schools and the top MWC schools. They all failed badly, but at least on the CUSA board people liked that he threw stuff against the wall in the public eye. I don’t see it myself but perception goes a long way.
The Marshall/Rice thing was definitely BS, but at least it gave us this: