(12-13-2010 10:25 AM)cmadler Wrote: (12-12-2010 05:25 PM)emu79 Wrote: Observation:So why everyone upset with Ramsey recruiting JUCOs and not with English for doing the same thing?
I totally agree with the comment that you build successful programs in football and basketball with high school kids over the long term.
1. It's proportionately worse for the basketball team. By my count, 10 players have been a non-trivial part of the team. Four of them -- 40% of the team -- transferred in this year, though Thompson is a D-I transfer, not a JUCO transfer. I don't have the numbers at hand, but I'd be shocked if 30% to 40% of football letterwinners were transfers.
2. The programs and coaches are, or should be, at differerent spots. English just finished his second year with the football team. He's still bringing in his players and installing his systems. Ramsey is in his sixth year. I'm fairly sure that everyone who's here, he recruited. If there are roster holes that needed emergency plugging, the holes were, at least in part, his doing.
3. Different sports are different. Basketball and football recruiting are not the same.
4. We complain mostly about football during football season and we complain mostly about basketball during basketball season. There were plenty of complaints on this message board about English's JUCOs a month or two ago; no one was talking about the basketball JUCOs at that point!
+2 post.
Very nicely thought out.
You said an awful lot in one concise post.
CMadler: As I have in another post, I don't believe one JUCO will start on offense for English next year.
Genyk did not leave the cupboard bare on offense and English stocked (restocked) it with high school kids.
On defense, the cupboard was somewhat depleted (some very good defenders had graduated in the two previous years) and re-stocking has been difficult.
BTW, here is my '11 'pre-spring drills' starting lineup:
Thomas, Scott, Hoskins, Buche, Sorgatz, Watman, Hansen, Neal, Gillett, Marrow, and Greene.
As should be, in English's 3rd year, 2/3s of the starters should be his.
I continue to get upset with INPATIENT fans who simply can not wait for coaches to build programs.
Fans who get all jacked up with recruiting expect that the kids will sign in February (or April or November in hoops) and make an immediate contribute 6 months or even 18 months later and save a program which has been down for a GENERATION.
EMU recruits
prospects not Suhs, Pryors, Newtons, etc.
What happened to the mentality that the first year the kid redshirts or comes off the bench, then the second year plays more and maybe starts, and then year 3 and 4 becomes a solid or impact player?