(01-24-2009 10:17 AM)WMD Owl Wrote: Obama's definition of "Bipartisanship":
Republicans give in now or I'll screw you worse on the floor of the House and Senate and sign whatever Pelosi and Reid send me.
Agree.
So what should the republicans do?
Obama obviously wants to toss them a bone or two, get them to sign on, and pass this as some "bipartisan" effort. Then he has a bully pulpit to go to the American people and say, "support this or you're unpatriotic." We're already seeing that.
What I think the republicans should do is to come up with an alternative, tell Obama that if he wants their votes he has to give them a significant portion, and if he doesn't (which he won't) then let things come down to a straight party-line vote. Then when things crater (and they will, because the Obama "plan" doesn't have a ghost of a chance to solve the real problems) the democrats will have nobody to blame but themselves. Do you want to crash and get it over with, or do you want to be nibbled to death by ducks? I vote for crash and get it over with. I'm afraid the republicans are going to have us nibbled to death by ducks, just as under the Shrub administration.
As for a patriotic obligation to support the Obama plan, Americans are under the same patriotic obligation to support that plan as they were to support the war in Iraq--or Vietnam. When things go as badly for the economic plan as they did in Iraq or Vietnam, if not worse, voicing opposition is not unpatriotic.
I've read several articles about the proposition that conservatives have better ideas, but liberals have better people. I think there's some value to that idea. Obama has been elected president because he is a more attractive personality than McCain (or, probably more properly, Shrub). If Obama ran agianst either Shrub or McCain (or Hillary, but not Bill), and personality were the only issue, I'd vote for Obama.
The republicans have tried to fight the personality fight instead of the idea fight. They will usually lose the personality fight, although arguably Shrub won twice becuase he was a more likeable guy than Gore or Kerry. The last time republicans really fought the idea battle was the 1994 congressional elections, when they won spectacularly. Unfortunately they got so busy hating Bill Clinton (who was personally likeable, and whom I liked) that they forgot to stay on track. The republicans need a new Contract With America, and then they need to get on message and stay there.
It is one thing to say that the Obama plan makes no sense. It is a better thing to say that the Obama plan makes no sense, but here is an alternative that does. The republicans don't have that alternative now. Until they do, they are just rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.