(09-23-2019 11:17 AM)DirtyDukes Wrote:  

(09-20-2019 12:43 PM)ShadyP Wrote:  

(09-20-2019 12:39 PM)JMUska Wrote:  Does Schor still have eligibility?

If not, what's the point of comparing him to the best quarterback we have on our team?

Right.....and if we want to talk best JMU QB, sorry Schor ain't that guy either.

(09-23-2019 10:49 AM)JMad03 Wrote:  Schor is definitely one of the greats, but let's not forget about his interceptions. In 2017, he only had three games all year he didn't throw an INT (11/4 URI, 12/2 Stony Brook, and 12/16 South Dakota State). In the national championship game, he threw 2 INTs. 14 total interceptions.
He even threw interceptions versus ETSU and Norfolk State. Imagine if Ben did that.
DiNucci so far has only thrown 1 INT all season, yet he gets talked about like he's been throwing them every game. I understand most of the hate this guy gets is from last season, but this is 2019. It's obvious he wants to win, he loves it here and has been putting in the work to be better and appears to be working so far. He is one of the best QBs in FCS in 2019 and he doesn't deserve the amount of crap he gets from us. If he has another 3+ turnover game I'd say it would be deserved. Until then, lay off the guy and support JMUs QB.

Schor took us past the quarters? Who cares if his stats are better but he loses the big game?

What's Nooch's best win?

Those 2 INTs vs NDSU in 2017 certainly didn't win us the game, but you don't hear much about those.
I'm not going to say Ben was great last year, because he was incredibly inconsistent. But he did show moments last year (NC State for example) that showed us what kind of QB he was capable of being. He had 2 games that were probably some of the worst QB performances. The problem is that the rest of his career has been completely shadowed by those two games.. perhaps rightfully so. But the guy is not garbage. He will gladly admit his mistakes which should be more of a reason to like the guy.
Last year's team (DiNucci aside) just wasn't as good as 2016/17. Our offensive line last year was terrible, but that gets overshadowed. IMO that's a big reason we weren't as good last year. We had a hard time getting the running game going at times not to mention DiNucci trying to avoid sacks (which let to some pretty nice QB runs).
Putting the entire blame on Ben for last year just isn't fair. Colgate was a dumpster fire, but we still had a chance in that game. Don't forget the Houston drama and there's no wonder we didn't win.