So one of CoastGuard's nerd friends over at W&M posted this on their board and I thought it was pretty interesting. Much like Wins Above Replacement (WAR) in baseball, it seems there's a basketball version known as "Win Shares". I don't understand how it works at all beyond that, but here it is:
http://csnbbs.com/thread-810432.html
Win Shares ---- Player ---- Win Shares per 40 minutes
3.7 Joe Chealey JR Charleston .231
2.8 Devontae Cacok SO Wilmington .231
2.8 Justin Wright-Foreman SO Hofstra .177
2.7 Daniel Dixon SR William & Mary .201
2.5 Tyler Seibring SO Elon .165
2.4 Jarrell Brantley SO Charleston .171
2.4 TJ Williams SR Northeastern .147
2.3 Grant Riller FR Charleston .171
2.3 CJ Bryce SO Wilmington .147
2.3 Jackson Kent SR James Madison .139
2.2 Denzel Ingram SR Wilmington .143
2.1 Dainan Swoope SO Elon .132
2.0 Chris Flemmings SR Wilmington .131
1.7 John Davis SR Towson .203
1.7 Arnaud Adala Moto SR Towson .140
1.5 Jack Whitman JR William & Mary .145
1.5 Brian Hawkins JR Elon .124
1.5 Bolden Brace FR Northeastern .115
1.5 Steve Santa Ana SO Elon .110
1.5 Rodney Williams SR Drexel .098
1.5 Ryan Daly FR Delaware .089
1.4 Nick Harris SO Charleston .136
1.4 Ambrose Mosley SR Wilmington .123
1.4 Deshaun Morman JR Towson .117
1.4 Alex Murphy SR Northeastern .103
1.4 Dmitri Thompson JR Elon .103
1.3 Nathan Knight FR William & Mary .176
1.3 Ramone Snowden JR James Madison .099
1.3 Omar Prewitt SR William & Mary .095
1.3 Eli Pemberton FR Hofstra .089
1.2 Anthony Green SO Northeastern .120
1.2 Paulius Satkus SR James Madison .112
1.2 Mike Morsell JR Towson .105
1.2 Deron Powers SR Hofstra .077
1.1 Ivan Lukic SR James Madison .121
1.1 Devon Begley JR Northeastern .091
1.1 Sammy Mojica JR Drexel .076
1.1 Kurk Lee FR Drexel .071
1.0 Hunter Sabety JR Hofstra .150
1.0 Jordan Talley JR Wilmington .126
1.0 Joey McLean JR James Madison .073
So it would seem that Chealey was the most valuable player in the league, with Chealey and Cacok tied for being the most valuable players on a per minute basis.
We also have 4 players in the Top 13 on this list. Sounds about right on all counts.